bartop
Getting Started with Great Books in the Classroom
A Tutorial for K-12 Educators

header

Site Outline

What's New

Tutorial Home

Tutorial Lessons:

1. JGB in Action

2. Questions for
    Discussions

3. Leading
    Discussions

4. Getting Ready
    to Discuss

    FAQ

    Glossary

    The Literature

    Checklist

    Training
    Program

    Great Books     Research

    About Us


Discussion

Recent Discussion
Create New Topic

Members

Join Now
Login

Prev | Next | Questions for Junior Great Books Discussions

Questions for Junior Great Books Discussions

It's All About Interpretation

The kind of question the leader asks determines the kind of discussion, and even the kind of thinking, that will happen. In Shared Inquiry we distinguish three kinds of questions.

To explore the three kinds of questions, click on a menu item. Details will appear to the right.

Shared Inquiry Discussion focuses on interpretive questions.

About Interpretive Questions

An interpretive question has more than one answer that can be supported with evidence from the text.

"Ah! you don't know what these beans are," said the man. "If you plant them overnight, by morning they grow right up to the sky."

"Really?" says Jack. "You don't say so."

Does Jack believe that the beans will grow right up to the sky?

Parts of the story will support the idea that Jack does believe the man's words, but other parts suggest that he does not. "Really, you don't say so" might be sarcastic and condescending, or it might be naive.

Simply knowing what the text says is not enough. If we want to understand Jack and this story, we need to figure out what the text means by these words.

To answer an interpretive question, the reader must figure out what the text means by what it says.

Readers enjoy, learn, and live fuller, more enriched lives because they can make sense of what they read. To interpret is to make sense. It is perhaps the most human and most important activity of the mind.

Sublessons:

Prev | Next | Questions for Junior Great Books Discussions


Home | Programs | Training | Participate | Contacts

Copyright 2005 - The Great Books Foundation
Getting Started with Great Books in the Classroom

What is Shared Inquiry Discussion (SID)?
Shared Inquiry is the heart of Junior Great Books activities.
More about SID...


How do students benefit from Shared Inquiry Discussion? Shared Inquiry helps students develop ideas and share them with others.
Features of Shared Inquiry...
JGB learning objectives...


The best introduction to Shared Inquiry and using Junior Great Books is the Basic Leader Training Course.
More on JGB training...